Friday, July 13, 2012

So Far from So Close: The Eschatology of Mat Kearney's 'Young Love'

This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.
Six months ago I couldn’t have imagined writing an appreciative review of an album by an artist whose music is frequently described as a unique blend of folk, hip-hop, and Brit-pop (think Coldplay for the latter genre).
The Coldplay connection is ultimately responsible for this development. Despite the canonical status of U2 in my playlist, I confess to liking Coldplay’s sound enough to download a few songs. Early this year while writing at the Broad River Coffee Company across the street from Gardner-Webb University, I kept hearing a couple of songs I assumed were tracks I hadn’t yet heard from Coldplay’s latest studio release. A quick Google search for lyric fragments revealed they were actually by singer-songwriter Mat Kearney (pronounced “Carney”)—whose music, I realized, I’d heard before on Grey’s Anatomy episodes.
Kearney’s voice does sound a bit like Chris Martin’s minus the yodel-like effect, though pitched a little lower and with a hint of Bruce Hornsby. But I found Kearney’s songwriting and the perspective that informs it so much more compelling than Coldplay that soon his albums were soundtracking my weekly trips to teach ecumenical theology at the Lutheran Theological Southern Seminary in South Carolina.
A good part of what attracts me to the music of both U2 and Mat Kearney, stylistically disparate though they are, is the eschatological framework that makes their art a Christian rendering of the world.
“Eschatology,” the division of Christian theology that deals with “last things,” isn’t only about what happens at the end. Baptist theologian James Wm. McClendon, Jr. helpfully defined eschatology much more broadly: it’s “about what lasts; it is also about what comes last, and about the history that leads from the one to the other.” Eschatology has to do with God’s goals for all creation, from creation to consummation and everything in between, as well as our participation in what God is already doing to realize these goals in a world where they are manifestly not yet fully realized.
That framework is indispensable for a full appreciation of Kearney’s music. By nurture and owned conviction, it’s the set of lenses through which he’s been reading the world since he began making music with his roommate’s guitar while majoring in English literature at California State University, Chico on a soccer scholarship. While he credits his personal embrace of Christian faith to a serious read of the Bible in a religious studies course, Kearney is the son of a pastor: his mother Shannon Kearney was founding pastor of SouthHills Church in Eugene, Oregon and continues to serve as associate pastor there.
Kearney’s songs rarely invoke the Christian framework they presuppose with direct specificity. In an interview published a few months before the release of his first major label album he explained, “My faith is a part of who I am and the music I make. But it has to exist within the world that does not necessarily believe what I believe.” In keeping with Emily Dickinson’s admonition, Kearney tells truth in his music, but tells it slant.
For those who have ears to hear, Kearney tells the truth of Christian eschatology on his current albumYoung Love (2011), his third major label release. Despite what the title may suggest, it’s not a collection of maudlin love ballads. Young Love is about the eschatology of relationships.
Its ten tracks occupy the theological space of the tension between the “already” and the “not yet” of those relationships—the sheer exhilaration of meeting, falling in love with, and pursuing the person with whom you want to spend the rest of your life (“Hey Mama,” “She Got the Honey,” “Young and Dumb and in Love”), coupled with the inevitable conflict and struggle involved in continuing the relationship toward its goal (“Ships in the Night,” “Sooner or Later”), lived out in a world in which we all have our “backs against the wall” (an image invoked with precisely that wording in no less than three songs—“Count on Me,” “Sooner or Later,” and “Down”).
On this album Kearney deals honestly with the “not yet” of relationships in a way that sets his music apart from the overly realized eschatology of the CCM industry’s typical products, which tend to emphasize the present reality of “the power of his resurrection” with little place for “the sharing of his sufferings” (Philippians 3:10). “Sooner or Later” gets it right: “We’re all waiting on a dream that’s hard to own…Trying to feel the high without the low.”
Without losing the dream that what lasts and comes last can yet be experienced in the history that leads from the one to the other, Young Love names the low that belongs to this history: a marital spat and a wife’s fear that it portends the same eventual outcome as her parents’ dissolved marriage, a friend who keeps “Chasing the Light” but hasn’t yet found it, a lonely man who experiences redemption only at the point of preparations to end his life, a father-to-be who learns his house is headed for foreclosure, a teenage girl’s depressed existence in a broken home, an endless coffee shop parade of the faces of “falling love,” and a father’s struggles with the legacy of his relationship with his own father.
In the midst of these stories of lives longing for wholeness, “Hallelujah”—among the more direct lyrical allusions on the album to the biblical story of redemption—is transformed from a straightforward exhortation to praise God into a desperate embrace of God at the end of one’s rope. One instance is in “Learning to Love Again,” a gem of a song that re-narrates a life thought meaningless as the real self of God’s creative and re-creative work.
The other is in “Down,” which features a chorus that’s downright psalm-like in its questioning of whether the divine can “hear when we call, there where we fall, standing our backs against the wall”—questions answered in a song four tracks prior. “Count on Me,” ostensibly expressing a parent’s love for a child, is theological double entendre: “when your number’s called, back’s against the wall, pick you up when you call, be there where you fall…you can count on me.” Just in case anyone missed the connection, the set lists of Kearney’s concerts in support of the album have juxtaposed the two songs.
The narrative particularity of the history that leads from what lasts to what comes last is what Kearney does especially well. The essential stuff of Christian faith and faithfulness is the divine story that in Christ embraces the human story as well, giving us the story that helps us re-narrate our own stories and the world in which we live them out—which is another way of saying it’s all about eschatology. Like Augustine’s Confessions in which the ancient Bishop of Hippo re-narrated his own story in light of the story of God disclosed in Christ, Kearney’s music is almost always either autobiographical or rooted in the biographies of people he knows, the untidy details narrated within the framework of Christian eschatology.
“Ships in the Night,” for example, was sketched out on a plane flight after an argument between Kearney and his wife, model Annie Sims (who’s also the inspiration of the three songs about the exhilaration of young love). The album’s final track “Rochester” is the story of Mat’s father Michael Kearney and the gracious transformation of his life occasioned by a revelatory interaction with Mat’s older brother Benjamin.
These and other stories find their place in God’s story by virtue of their relation to the central experience and practice of the Christian story and its eschatological framework. In the words of “Down,” “we all need forgiveness”—the experience of receiving God’s forgiveness and the forgiveness of others, and the practice of granting in turn to others the forgiveness we’ve received.
Young Love is music for those who know the wonder of young love yet feel “so far from so close,” whose “singing Hallelujah” comes when they’re “looking down the barrel,” who live “where pain and love bleed into one.” It’s for people who embrace what lasts and comes last but live fully in the history that leads from the one to the other, a history that includes both the pain of the present evil age and the hope of the age to come.
I’m looking forward to discovering how this framework informs Kearney’s next project, on which he’s reportedly been working during a break in his touring schedule. In the meantime, I’ll enjoy seeing his show when he comes to Charlotte as the opening act for Train on July 26—along with our six-year-old son Timothy the budding music critic, who recently made the pronouncement “Mat Kearney is awesome,” constantly listens to Kearney’s songs on his Kindle Fire, and really, really hopes that he will sing “Count on Me” in Charlotte.
And by the way—the "unique blend of folk, hip-hop, and Brit-pop" thing works for me, after all.
This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Baptists and Episcopalians, One in Christ

In my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity, I suggested this as something that "ordinary Christians" can do locally to further the visible unity of the church: "If your own denomination has been in...official dialogue with other churches, studying and discussing these reports would be an ideal way to learn about other denominations and their relationship to your own tradition" (pp. 63-64).

Two churches in Shelby, North Carolina are trying that suggestion out together this week. For the second year in a row, Ross Grove Baptist Church and the Episcopal Church of the Redeemer are joining forces for a joint Vacation Bible School, which this summer also features an "adult track." The world communions of the two churches, the Baptist World Alliance and the Anglican Communion, held a series of conversations 2000-2005 that produced a substantial study text. In connection with that document, Sunday through Tuesday and Thursday evening this week I'm leading a group of members from both congregations in a four-part study of the theme "Baptists and Episcopalians, One in Christ." Here are the topics we're discussing:

  • "A Shared Story: From Separation and Persecution to Toleration to Ecumenical Engagement"
  • "Common Prayer? Occasion for Division, Opportunity for Convergence"
  • "One Baptism? Comparable Journeys of Christian Initiation"
  • "One Bread, One Body? Together at the Table"
  • "So What? Living Into Our Unity"
I'll write more about this study and possibilities for similar steps toward unity at the grassroots in a future blog post for the ABPnews Blog, which I'll also link here and eventually post the full text here as well.

Monday, July 9, 2012

The eschatology of 'Young Love'

Today the ABPnews Blog published my post The Eschatology of 'Young Love'. I'll post the full text here later this week. In the meantime, a couple of teaser excerpts:

...A good part of what attracts me to the music of both U2 and Mat Kearney, stylistically disparate though they are, is the eschatological framework that makes their art a Christian rendering of the world....

...For those who have ears to hear, Kearney tells the truth of Christian eschatology on his current album Young Love (2011), his third major label release. Despite what the title may suggest, it’s not a collection of maudlin love ballads. Young Love is about the eschatology of relationships....

Read the full post on the ABPnews Blog.

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Baptist World Alliance gathers in Santiago, Chile

This week members of the global Baptist community are participating in the annual gathering of the Baptist World Alliance in Santiago, Chile. I'm not in attendance this year, but my "Report on Pre-Conversations between Representatives of the Baptist World Alliance and the Orthodox Ecumenical Patriarchate" will be presented in absentia to the BWA Commission on Doctrine and Christian Unity during the gathering. The Doctrine and Christian Unity commission will also hear and discuss reports in connection with the 2006-2010 series of conversations between the BWA and the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity and a new series of conversations with representatives of the global Pentecostal movement that will begin later this year and will discuss papers contemplating Baptist responses to the recently approved World Council of Churches Faith and Order paper on The Nature and Mission of the Church (an earlier draft of which is available on the WCC web site--click on hyperlinked title). Other BWA commission and affinity group meetings are listed in the annual gathering schedule.

In connection with the planned discussions of The Nature and Mission of the Church, BWA General Secretary Neville Callam issued this column in the electronic publication BWA Connect:


Thinking about the church and its mission
By Neville Callam


Recently, I had the pleasure of reading Graham Hill’s book, Salt, Light, and a City: Introducing Missional Ecclesiology. I started reading this book a mere two days after the Standing Commission on Faith and Order voted to approve what is expected to be a significant convergence text on the church. This text, which should soon appear in print, is the product of years of serious multilateral theological engagement by the Faith and Order Commission.

It is clear that Hill’s book also represents years of serious research and reflection. The book, the first of a planned multiple volume series, probes some of the existing understandings of the nature of the church and its missional activity with a view to developing a coherent vision of its central subject from the perspective of Protestant evangelicalism.

In the first section, Hill offers an overview of understandings of the church reflected in the writings of selected theologians. Perspectives from the various church traditions are discussed in concise chapters on “twelve important theologians” -- Joseph Ratzinger (Pope Benedict XVI), Karl Rahner and Hans Kung from the Catholic Church; Thomas Hopko, Vigen Guroian and John Zizioulas from the Orthodox Church; Letty Russell, Jurgen Moltman and John Webster from the Protestant Church community; and John Yoder, Barry Harvey and Miroslav Volf from the Free Churches.

In the second section, Hill offers a preliminary vision of the missional church that is informed by his “biblical, Reformed evangelical, Christ-centered, Free Church, charismatic, trinitarian, ecumenical, and missional convictions.” This vision comes out of a dialogue with the perspectives skillfully summarized in Part 1 of his book.

Hill’s is an important work that will be read by Christians who care that the corporate practice of Christian discipleship and mission that they affirm and teach is rooted in a defensible biblical and theological foundation.

Before criticizing Hill for engaging in dialogue with theologians from parts of the world where, he says, “Christianity finds itself now on the margins of a culture in which it once enjoyed a central place”, let us carefully note -- and eagerly await -- his promise of a second volume in which he will focus on theological reflections on the church and its mission as reflected in the writings of theologians from other parts of the world. Those whose theological contribution he intends to discuss include Leonardo Boff, Jon Sobrino, Juan Segundo, Samuel Escobar, Rene Padilla, Kwame Bediako, John Mbiti, Oliver Onwubiko, Tite Tiénou and Peter Phan, “to name a few.”

It will be interesting to see how Hill analyzes the interaction of context, culture, experience, and confessional/theological tradition in his assessment of the understandings of the church reflected in the writings of such scholars. Since the same interplay is at work in the ecclesiologies Hill analyzes and proposes in Salt, Light and a City,one waits to see whether there will be similarity in the recognition of the role played by these factors in the formulation of the theological positions analyzed in Hill’s upcoming publication.

For the time being, however, it is important for Baptists to read and reflect on the first text in which Hill offers much that justifies the time needed to read his book. Hill offers a window into existing understandings of the church and their implication for mission “from a Euro-American perspective” emerging in western cultures where churches “are mostly experiencing decline, marginality, and liminality.” He also engages the creative process of developing a constructive Australian missional theology that is “self-consciously western.”

The Faith and Order text, which one expects to reflect contributions and perspectives from the worldwide Christian community, focuses on the church and its unity in the service of its mission. This text is also informed by the ecclesiologies with which Hill engages in conversation -- and indeed some of the scholars whose work Hill has accessed and plans to draw upon actually participated in the deliberations of Faith and Order.

By the time we conclude our reading of Hill’s Salt, Light and a City and its upcoming companion volume, which together will harvest what Hill regards as the best fruits of conversations with theologians from the West and from the Majority World, the full sweep of Hills’ vision of the missional church will become clear. Only then will we be able to ascertain how Hill’s vision compares with that conveyed in the Faith and Order Commission’s differently-focused text on the church.

Hill’s book is a must read for church leaders and teachers who care about the church and its mission. I welcome Salt, Light and a City and, with the same enthusiasm, await his upcoming volume.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Cooperative Baptists and trans-local Eucharists

CBF General Assembly 2008
A version of this post previously appeared on the ABPnews Blog.



Cooperative Baptists are Baptists who “do this” when they get together. They “do this” not only in their local churches but also in their assemblies and in the institutions of theological education with which they partner.

I’m talking about the fact that when Baptists who identify with the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship gather in settings beyond their local churches, they often follow the Lord’s admonition to “do this in remembrance of me” by celebrating the Eucharist. That’s what I found myself contemplating last week after receiving the Eucharist at the 2012 CBF General Assembly—and at the associated gathering of Baptist Women in Ministry two days prior.

That’s something entirely different from my experience as a Southern Baptist from the “cradle roll” through seminary. To be sure, we observed the Lord’s Supper in our local churches (though rarely more frequently than four times a year). But to share in the Lord’s Supper in a worship service at an associational meeting, a state convention, a Southern Baptist Convention meeting, or a seminary chapel service would have been unthinkable—maybe even heretical. That was something only local churches did.

Cooperative Baptists have evidently not felt bound by that aspect of their heritage. It bears reflection that when those who now identify with the CBF have had the freedom to do something other than what they did as Southern Baptists, they have chosen to celebrate the Eucharist in gatherings that, while not baptizing communities, are communities of the baptized.

That Cooperative Baptists “do this” means at the very least that, despite a post-General Assembly Fort Worth Star-Telegram article that characterized the CBF as an organization that “has no doctrine,” they have at least one first-order practice that embodies a first-order conviction. (To be sure, there are others.) Cooperative Baptists seem to be convinced that it is important enough to “do this” that they rarely gather beyond their local churches without doing it.

This calls for some second-order theological reflection. What does the celebration of the Eucharist beyond the local church imply about the ecclesiology (a doctrine!) of Cooperative Baptists that distinguishes it from the ecclesiology of its parent Baptist communion?

The late Mennonite theologian John Howard Yoder wrote in an essay published in The Royal Priesthood: Essays Ecclesiological and Ecumenical (Herald Press, 1994): “The ‘high’ views of ordered churchdom can legitimate the worship of a General Assembly or a study conference only by stretching the rules, for its rules do not foresee ad hoc ‘churches’; only thoroughgoing congregationalism fulfills its hopes and definities whenever and wherever it sees ‘church’ happen” (p. 236).

Do Cooperative Baptist thoroughgoing congregationalists likewise see ‘church’ happening in their General Assemblies? Their eucharistic practice points in that direction.

Baptist World Alliance General Secretary Neville Callam has insisted that global Baptists need to do serious theological reflection on the ecclesial status of the BWA. I wonder—might this be the time for us to do serious theological reflection on the ecclesial status of the CBF as well in light of our eucharistic practice?

If Cooperative Baptists believe there is sufficient ecclesiological warrant for them to “do this” when they gather, they are granting some degree of ecclesiality—characteristics of church—to their trans-local gatherings. And if that’s the case, might there be ecclesiological warrant for Cooperative Baptists to do as a gathered community of the baptized other things that reflect this ecclesiality? What might those other things be?

If we are enough of a eucharistic community that we believe we ought to “do this” when we gather beyond our local churches, we need to make sure that there is a corresponding practiced conviction in the local churches from which we gather. There’s something not quite right locally when, if I belonged to a congregation that celebrated communion only four times a year, I would receive the Eucharist more times at the national and state General Assemblies of the CBF, the national and state gatherings of Baptist Women in Ministry, and occasional divinity school chapel services combined than I would in such a local Baptist congregation.

Celebration of the Eucharist beyond the local church is already a distinguishing practice of Cooperative Baptists that sets them apart from some other sorts of Baptists. Let’s give this fact, its implications for the ecclesial status of the CBF, and its relation to the practices of our local congregations the theological reflection these matters deserve.


A version of this post previously appeared on the ABPnews Blog.

Monday, June 25, 2012

Baptists who "do this"

My post "Baptists who 'do this'" appears today on the Associated Baptist Press ABPnews Blog (click on hyperlinked title). I'll be able to post the full text here on Ecclesial Theology later this week. In the meantime, here's a snippet from the opening:


Cooperative Baptists are Baptists who “do this” when they get together. They “do this” not only in their local churches but also in their assemblies and in the institutions of theological education with which they partner....That’s something entirely different from my experience as a Southern Baptist from the “cradle roll” through seminary.... (read the full post on ABPnews Blog)

Friday, June 22, 2012

The formation and reception of believer-theologians

Karl Barth
This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.


But on the other hand….

My college philosophy professor Wallace Roark taught me that cultivating the capacity to “think on the other hand”—to Think Like an Octopus—is the key to becoming a good thinker.

“But on the other hand” is also the necessary segue from my previous ABPnews Blog post on “The theologian-hood of all believers,” which concluded with this paragraph:

That sort of life together happens most fully when congregations promote and embrace the theologian-hood of all believers. Churches do that by forming all believers in the convictions and practices of Christian faithfulness they need if they are to fulfill their vocation as the church’s theologians, and churches do that by being willing to listen to the voices of all believers whenever they speak as the church’s theologians.

It is true that, as Karl Barth observed, “In the Church there really are no non-theologians.”

But on the other hand, believer-theologians must be formed. Birth in the baptismal waters does not automatically confer upon a believer the status of doctor ecclesiae, “teacher of the church.” Believer-theologians must be formed, and their formation is the responsibility of the church in which Christ is present as Teacher.

It is true that Matthew 13:51-52 in context compares disciples to theological teachers.

But on the other hand, they are like scribes “trained for the kingdom of heaven” through a process of rabbinical-style traditioning by Jesus that eventually, but not immediately, prepares them for their commissioning as authoritative teachers by the end of the Gospel of Matthew.

It is true that, as the framers of the “Re-envisioning Baptist Identity” statement trust, “When all exercise their gifts and callings, when every voice is heard and weighed, when no one is silenced or privileged, the Spirit leads communities to read wisely and to practice faithfully the direction of the gospel.”

But on the other hand, the voices of believer-theologians must be received with discernment, weighed in accordance with their formation and their particular role in the church.

Barth wrote of the ecclesial formation of believer-theologians in a section on “Authority under the Word” in his Church Dogmatics:

But it is obvious that before I myself make a confession I must myself have heard the confession of the Church, i.e., the confession of the rest of the Church. In my hearing and receiving of the Word of God I cannot separate myself from the Church to which it is addressed. I cannot thrust myself into the debate about a right faith which goes on in the Church without first having listened….If I am to confess my faith generally with the whole Church and in that confession be certain that my faith is the right faith, then I must begin with the community of faith and therefore hear the Church’s confession of faith as it comes to me from other members of the Church. And for that very reason I recognise an authority, a superiority in the Church: namely, that the confession of others who were before me in the Church and are beside me in the Church is superior to my confession if this really is an accounting and responding in relation to my hearing and receiving of the Word of God, if it really is my confession as that of a member of the body of Christ (CD I/2, p. 589).

All members of the community have voices that must be heard and not silenced, but not all members have first fully heard the confession of those who are before them and beside them in the church. Someone might regard the distinctively Christian doctrine of God as Trinity, for example, as optional or maybe even as necessarily rejected because it supposedly reflects the coercive imposition of arbitrary ecclesial authority backed by imperial power. But such a voice has not been fully formed by the church’s Trinitarian confession, and his or her voice must be weighed accordingly.

This is the point at which there is a proper distinction between the theologian-hood of all believers and the role of those who have distinctive vocations as the church’s theologians: pastors, whose charge includes serving as theologians-in-residence for the congregations they serve by “watching over” the integrity of their telling of the Christian story, and theological educators, whose charge includes the theological formation of these pastors.

The voices of those who have distinctive vocations as the church’s theologians are not infallible. Indeed, they can lead astray (as they sometimes have). But they carry distinctive weight, and must be weighed accordingly.

But on the other hand, doesn’t allowing for the possibility that some voices may be weightier than others raise the troubling question of who ultimately decides what represents integrity in the telling of the Christian story?

My forthcoming book on the Baptist vision and the ecumenical future includes a chapter on “magisterium,” which has to do with the configuration of teaching authority in the church. It is not only the Catholic Church that has magisterium. All churches, including Baptist ones, depend upon magisterium for the integrity of their telling of the Christian story.

I’m tempted to flesh out that assertion in my next ABPnews Blog post. But on the other hand, I think I’ll leave the explanation of that one to the book.

This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

The formation and reception of believer-theologians

Today my blog post "The formation and reception of believer-theologians" appeared on the ABPnews Blog published by Associated Baptist Press (click on hyperlinked title). I'll be able to post the full text here on Ecclesial Theology later this week; in the meantime, here's a snippet:


But on the other hand….

My college philosophy professor Wallace Roark taught me that cultivating the capacity to “think on the other hand”—to Think Like an Octopus—is the key to becoming a good thinker.

“But on the other hand” is also the necessary segue from my previous ABPnews Blog post on “The Theologian-hood of all believers,” which concluded with this paragraph:

That sort of life together happens most fully when congregations promote and embrace the theologian-hood of all believers. Churches do that by forming all believers in the convictions and practices of Christian faithfulness they need if they are to fulfill their vocation as the church’s theologians, and churches do that by being willing to listen to the voices of all believers whenever they speak as the church’s theologians.

It is true that, as Karl Barth observed, “In the Church there really are no non-theologians.”

But on the other hand.... (read the rest of the blog post on the ABPnews Blog).

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Baptists, history, and theology

W. Glenn Jonas, Jr.,
Nurturing the Vision
Last week I had the pleasure of participating in the annual conference of the Baptist History and Heritage Society held at First Baptist Church in Raleigh, North Carolina in conjunction with the celebration of the 200th anniversary of that congregation's founding. This year's theme (and primary reason for my participation) was "Baptists and Theology."

Three plenary speakers addressed the conference theme and location. W. Glenn Jonas, Jr., Charles B. Howard Professor of Religion and Chair of the Department of Religion at Campbell University in Buies Creek, North Carolina, drew on research for his book Nurturing the Vision: First Baptist Church, Raleigh , 1812-2012 (Mercer University Press, 2012) in his opening presentation "Nurturing the Vision: Highlights from the History of a 200-Year-Old Baptist Church in Raleigh." Bill Leonard, Dunn Chair of Baptist Studies at Wake Forest University School of Divinity in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, delivered the address "Conviction and Contradiction: Reassessing Theological Formation in Baptist Identity," and Fisher Humphreys, retired Professor of Divinity at Samford University's Beeson Divinity School in Birmingham, Alabama, presented the concluding address "To Go Forward We Must Go Back: Baptist Theology Since 1950."

The interest of veteran and emerging Baptist historians and theologians in the conference theme was evident in the response to an open call for papers, which yielded a breakout session program of twenty-four papers presented in concurrent sessions. I was able to hear the following papers: "East, West, and Baptist: Finding the Body of Christ at the Lord's Supper" by Welford Orrock of Second Baptist Church in Richmond, Virginia; "Baptists and Sacramentalism: Engaging Recent Work in Baptist Sacramental Theology" By Tracey Stout of Bluefield College in Bluefield, Virginia; "Discovering and Debating the True Church: The Ecclesiology of Hanserd Knollys in 1645" by Bill Pitts of Baylor University in Waco, Texas; "A Cure for the Cankering Error" by Curtis Freeman of Duke University Divinity School in Durham, North Carolina; "Baptist Theology: Is There Another Way?" by Jay Smith of Yellowstone Theological Institute in Bozeman, Montana; and "Locating Baptist Dogmatics: Defining and Defending Identity in the Absence of a Normative Theology" by Philip Thompson of Sioux Falls Seminary in Sioux Falls, South Dakota.

I presented a paper on "Baptist Theology in Dialogue: Reports of International Bilateral Conversations with Baptist World Alliance Participation as Expressions of Baptist Constructive Theology," which reflected a portion of a chapter in my forthcoming book tentatively titled The Baptist Vision and the Ecumenical Future: Radicially Biblical, Radically Catholic, Relentlessly Orthodox under contract with Baylor University Press.

I'm grateful to the Baptist History and Heritage Society for providing this opportunity for Baptist historians and Baptist theologians to have a mutually enriching dialogue regarding our common object of academic inquiry--the Baptist tradition.


Thursday, June 7, 2012

The theologian-hood of all believers

This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.

Karl Barth (1886-1968), the most significant theologian of the twentieth century, wasn’t a Baptist (he was Swiss Reformed). Yet over the past sixty years Barth has arguably had at least as much influence on theologically-educated Baptists as any Baptist theologian during the same period.

Barth’s thought suggested a third way beyond fundamentalism and liberalism that provided a theological haven for many Baptist theologians and their students during the second half of the twentieth century. Late in his career Barth lent weighty ecumenical support to the Baptist emphasis on believer’s baptism as a disciple-making practice, endorsing its normativity from within a tradition that also baptizes infants.

A less well-known connection between Barth and the Baptist vision is a parallel between Baptist ways of emphasizing the priesthood of all believers and Barth’s emphasis on the responsibility of all believers for the church’s theology. Barth put it this way in a lecture delivered to the Free Protestant Theological Faculty in Paris in 1934:

[T]heology is not a private subject for theologians only. Nor is it a private subject for professors. Fortunately, there have always been pastors who have understood more about theology than most professors. Nor is theology a private subject of study for pastors. Fortunately, there have repeatedly been congregation members, and often whole congregations, who have pursued theology energetically while their pastors were theological infants or barbarians. Theology is a matter for the Church….But the problem of theology…is set before the whole Church. In the Church there are really no non-theologians. The concept “layman” is one of the worst concepts in religious terminology, a concept that should be eliminated from the Christian vocabulary. So, the [non*]-professors and the [non*]-pastors are co-responsible to see to it that the theology of the professors and pastors be a good one and not a bad one (Karl Barth, God in Action, trans. E. G. Homrighausen and Karl J. Ernst [T. & T. Clark, 1936], pp. 56-57).

We might call Barth’s concept the “theologian-hood of all believers.” Barth insisted that all Christians are together responsible for the church’s task of giving a wholesome account of its convictions regarding God and that with which God is in relationship—the convictions that the church must teach in order to bring its life together ever more fully under the rule of Christ.

The Gospel of Matthew hints at something like the theologian-hood of all believers. It portrays the disciples as theological teachers-in-training who progressively grow in their understanding of Jesus’ teaching until at the conclusion of the Gospel they too are commissioned as teachers. Matthew is structured around five teaching discourses, the middle of which is the series of “parables of the kingdom of heaven” in chapter 13. At their conclusion Jesus asks the disciples,

“Have you understood all this?” They answered, “Yes.” And he said to them, “Therefore every scribe who has been trained for the kingdom of heaven is like the master of a household who brings out of his treasure what is new and what is old” (Matt. 13:51-52 NRSV).

Here Jesus compares one of the tasks of the disciple to the role of a scribe. In first-century Judaism, a scribe was not merely a copyist but a specialist in the application of the law—“what is old”—to the changed circumstances of contemporary Jewish life centuries after the writing of the Hebrew Scriptures—“what is new.” They were the theologians of Jesus’ day. If the “Great Commission” at the conclusion of Matthew’s Gospel applies to all believers, then so does the parable of the scribe (theologian) trained for the kingdom of heaven. As Barth insisted, “In the Church there are really no non-theologians.”

The theologian-hood of all believers is embodied in what British Baptists call “church meeting.” Baptist theologian Paul Fiddes of Oxford University explains what it means for the church meeting to seek together the mind of Christ:

Upon the whole people in covenant there lies the responsibility of finding a common mind, of coming to an agreement about the way of Christ for them in life, worship and mission. But they cannot do so unless they use the resources that God has given them (Paul S. Fiddes, Tracks and Traces: Baptist Identity in Church and Theology [Paternoster, 2003], p. 86).

The resources that God has given the church for discerning the way of Christ include the theologians of the church—the theologians that are all believers as well as those who are pastors and professors of theology.

In 1997 a group of Baptist theologians in the United States affirmed the theologian-hood of all believers in relation to the church’s theological task of bringing out of the Scriptures “what is new and what is old”:

We affirm Bible Study in reading communities....We thus affirm an open and orderly process whereby faithful communities deliberate together over the Scriptures with sisters and brothers of the faith, excluding no light from any source. When all exercise their gifts and callings, when every voice is heard and weighed, when no one is silenced or privileged, the Spirit leads communities to read wisely and to practice faithfully the direction of the gospel (“Re-envisioning Baptist Identity: A Manifesto for Baptist Communities in North America,” § 1).

That sort of life together happens most fully when congregations promote and embrace the theologian-hood of all believers. Churches do that by forming all believers in the convictions and practices of Christian faithfulness they need if they are to fulfill their vocation as the church’s theologians, and churches do that by being willing to listen to the voices of all believers whenever they speak as the church’s theologians.

*Nerd note: The English translation of the German text of Barth’s lecture quoted above has it completely wrong at the points noted by asterisks; I’ve supplied my own translation in brackets (Barth wrote and published the lecture originally in German but delivered it in French). The translation by Homrighausen and Ernst reads [original German inserted in brackets], “So, the false professors [Nicht-Professoren] and the false pastors [Nicht-Pfarrer] are co-responsible to see to it that the theology of the professors and pastors be a good one and not a bad one.” But since two sentences before Barth wrote, “In the Church there are really no non-theologians [Nicht-Theologen],” it’s clear that Nicht-Professoren and Nicht-Pfarrer must be “non-professors” and “non-pastors.” If it weren’t for the 1936 publication date of the English translation by Homrighausen and Ernst, I’d have assumed that they resorted to a free web-based auto-translator. Let those who rely on translations beware! (For the truly nerdy: Barth’s lectures in Paris were originally published as Karl Barth, Offenbarung, Kirche, Theologie [Theologische Existenz Heute, no. 9; Munich: Chr. Kaiser Verlag, 1934; the material quoted above is from page 43.)

This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.