A recent issue of Studia Historicae Ecclesiasticae, the journal of the Church History Society of Southern Africa, includes a review of my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity (Eugene, Ore.: Cascade Books, 2010) by Professor Christina Landman, Director of the Research Institute for Theology and Religion at the University of South Africa in Pretoria, South Africa. The review, which appears in vol. 37, no. 1 (2011), p. 289, is a challenging reminder that a number of ecumenical issues look very different when viewed through the lenses of a social location in which ecclesial divisions are not merely matters of differing intellectual accounts of Christian faith or ecclesiological preferences. The recovery of the distinctiveness of denominational traditions as a means toward deeper convergences toward visible unity can suggest one thing in a North American or European context; it can mean something altogether different for a context in which the conservation of denominational distinctiveness was historically linked with the conservation of distinct racial identities that are purported to be "equal but different." Here's an excerpt from the midst of the review:
....Sometimes the word [ecumenism] simply refers to a modern tendency among Americans to casually exchange churches. In South Africa, this may be a habit among a few white people, but the majority of black people are committed to their churches through the wearing of uniforms. The author of the book is not himself at ease with this expression of "ecumenism" as "church hopping," and suggests that this be counteracted by believers being loyal to their denominations....[he] makes use of the concept of ecumenism to appeal to Christians to "unite," although this "oneness" does not imply sameness. Again, for South Africans this will smack of apartheid and its slogan: "Equal but different"....
I'm grateful for Professor Landman's review and its insistence that a thick ecumenical encounter deeply rooted in particular traditions must not become an excuse for a renewed denominationalism, especially in light of the modern ecumenical movement's insufficient attention to divisions of race and class as the more problematic and enduring divisions of the church.
Interested in Ecumenism Means You, Too? Order the book directly from the publisher or via Amazon.
Doing theology in, with, and for the church--in the midst of its divisions, and toward its visible unity in one eucharistic fellowship.
Thursday, August 23, 2012
"Violence and the cross" (ABPnews Blog post)
My post "Violence and the cross" appears today on the ABPnews Blog. I'll post the full text here in a few days; in the meantime, here's a snippet from the midst of the post:
....Some common ways of understanding how the cross of Christ reconciles us to God portray God as one who engages in redemptive violence. Human virtue reflects the divine character, so if the cross reveals the justice of a violently redemptive God, it stands to reason that people are justified when they fight violence with violence.
The cross is undeniably violent. But who is responsible for the violence of the cross event?...
(Read the full post on the ABPnews Blog)
....Some common ways of understanding how the cross of Christ reconciles us to God portray God as one who engages in redemptive violence. Human virtue reflects the divine character, so if the cross reveals the justice of a violently redemptive God, it stands to reason that people are justified when they fight violence with violence.
The cross is undeniably violent. But who is responsible for the violence of the cross event?...
(Read the full post on the ABPnews Blog)
Monday, August 20, 2012
ABPnews Blog post on "Christians, guns, and the myth of redemptive violence"
The ABPnews Blog has published my post "Christians, guns, and the myth of redemptive violence" from which my ABP News commentary "The myth of redemptive violence" that appeared earlier was adapted. Click on the hyperlinked titles for the post and adapted commentary; the full text of the ABPnews Blog post will appear here on Ecclesial Theology in a few days. In the meantime, here's an excerpt from the beginning of the post:
“How many more daughters, sons, mothers, fathers, sisters, brothers, grandmothers, grandfathers, aunts, uncles, cousins, husbands, wives, friends—people created by and in the very image of God—have to die a horrific death before Americans will learn to lay down their guns?”
That was the Facebook status update my wife Kheresa posted following the Aug. 5 shooting at the Sikh temple in Oak Creek, Wis. Her question succeeded in setting off a spirited week-long comment thread debate among Facebook friends from various dimensions of her life over the merits of gun control legislation.
The comments—some quite deeply reflected—spanned the spectrum of perspectives in the contemporary American debate over gun control and matched its heat (no pun intended). As a theologian who thinks that a lively debate within a contested tradition can be a sign of its health—and who thinks this is ultimately a theological issue—I jumped in. The following paragraphs are adapted from some of my comments....
(Read the rest of the post on the ABPnews Blog)
“How many more daughters, sons, mothers, fathers, sisters, brothers, grandmothers, grandfathers, aunts, uncles, cousins, husbands, wives, friends—people created by and in the very image of God—have to die a horrific death before Americans will learn to lay down their guns?”
That was the Facebook status update my wife Kheresa posted following the Aug. 5 shooting at the Sikh temple in Oak Creek, Wis. Her question succeeded in setting off a spirited week-long comment thread debate among Facebook friends from various dimensions of her life over the merits of gun control legislation.
The comments—some quite deeply reflected—spanned the spectrum of perspectives in the contemporary American debate over gun control and matched its heat (no pun intended). As a theologian who thinks that a lively debate within a contested tradition can be a sign of its health—and who thinks this is ultimately a theological issue—I jumped in. The following paragraphs are adapted from some of my comments....
(Read the rest of the post on the ABPnews Blog)
Tuesday, August 14, 2012
"The myth of redemptive violence"
The Associated Baptist Press has published my guest commentary "The myth of redemptive violence," adapted from a forthcoming post for the ABPnews Blog. The tag line and lead paragraph appear below; click on hyperlink for the full commentary at ABP News.
The myth of redemptive violence
America’s love affair with guns stems from a deeper assumption that it is possible to fight violence with violence.
By Steve Harmon
The Aug. 5 shooting at the Sikh temple in Oak Creek, Wis., has set off spirited debate over the merits of gun-control legislation. As a theologian who thinks that a lively debate within a contested tradition can be a sign of its health -- and who thinks this is ultimately a theological issue -- I will jump in.... (Read the full commentary at ABP News)
The myth of redemptive violence
America’s love affair with guns stems from a deeper assumption that it is possible to fight violence with violence.
By Steve Harmon
The Aug. 5 shooting at the Sikh temple in Oak Creek, Wis., has set off spirited debate over the merits of gun-control legislation. As a theologian who thinks that a lively debate within a contested tradition can be a sign of its health -- and who thinks this is ultimately a theological issue -- I will jump in.... (Read the full commentary at ABP News)
Thursday, August 9, 2012
Update on Baptist-Pentecostal dialogue
The Baptist World Alliance has issued the following press release regarding the postponement of the first meeting of the upcoming dialogue between representatives of the BWA and the Pentecostal World Fellowship:
Baptist-Pentecostal Dialogue
Washington, DC (BWA)-- The following is a release on the Baptist-Pentecostal dialogue from BWA General Secretary Neville Callam and Cecil Robeck, Jr., of the Pentecostals:
Following discussions between Dr. Cecil M. Robeck, Jr., and Rev. Neville Callam at the meeting of the Committee of Secretaries of Christian World Communions in Geneva in 2010, a proposal was developed for an international theological dialogue between scholars from the Baptist and Pentecostal traditions. This proposal received the blessings of the Pentecostal World Fellowship and the Baptist World Alliance.
At a preparatory meeting that took place at Beeson Divinity School, Samford University, in Birmingham, Alabama, USA, in 2011, the parameters for the dialogue were agreed and the first meeting of the International Commission was scheduled to take place in Quito, Ecuador, August 4-11, 2012.
Recently, representatives of the Baptist World Alliance and the Pentecostals announced their joint decision to postpone the commencement of their international dialogue owing to an unexpected change in personnel at the venue for the meetings and also the unavailability of some participants who were scheduled to be in attendance.
The partners to the dialogue are negotiating the re-scheduling of the commencement date for this important dialogue that is planned to extend over a three-year period.
Rev. Neville Callam
Dr. Cecil M. Robeck, Jr.
Baptist-Pentecostal Dialogue
Washington, DC (BWA)-- The following is a release on the Baptist-Pentecostal dialogue from BWA General Secretary Neville Callam and Cecil Robeck, Jr., of the Pentecostals:
Following discussions between Dr. Cecil M. Robeck, Jr., and Rev. Neville Callam at the meeting of the Committee of Secretaries of Christian World Communions in Geneva in 2010, a proposal was developed for an international theological dialogue between scholars from the Baptist and Pentecostal traditions. This proposal received the blessings of the Pentecostal World Fellowship and the Baptist World Alliance.
At a preparatory meeting that took place at Beeson Divinity School, Samford University, in Birmingham, Alabama, USA, in 2011, the parameters for the dialogue were agreed and the first meeting of the International Commission was scheduled to take place in Quito, Ecuador, August 4-11, 2012.
Recently, representatives of the Baptist World Alliance and the Pentecostals announced their joint decision to postpone the commencement of their international dialogue owing to an unexpected change in personnel at the venue for the meetings and also the unavailability of some participants who were scheduled to be in attendance.
The partners to the dialogue are negotiating the re-scheduling of the commencement date for this important dialogue that is planned to extend over a three-year period.
Rev. Neville Callam
Dr. Cecil M. Robeck, Jr.
Friday, August 3, 2012
10 Things You Can Do for the Unity of the Church--Flagler Beach, FL edition
With my permission, the web sites of the Christian Unity Ministry of Santa Maria Del Mar Catholic Church in Flagler Beach, Florida and Flagler Churches Together in Prayer and Song have posted a synopsis of "Leaves You if You Don't Care for It: Ten Things You Can Do for the Unity of the Church," chapter 4 in my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity (click on hyperllinks for the synopses as they appear on the respective web sites). Many thanks to Dr. Chau T. Phan, a retired professor of political science, member of Santa Maria Del Mar Catholic Church, and lay advocate for the unity of the church, for calling attention to the book in this way. Readers of Ecclesial Theology will find Dr. Phan's account of his calling to this lay ecumenical vocation interesting and inspiring. I also encourage having a look around the web site of the Christian Unity Ministry coordinated by Dr. Phan at Santa Maria Del Mar Catholic Church--the most active local church effort at grassroots ecumenical engagement I've come across to date.
Interested in reading Ecumenism Means You, Too? Order the book directly from the publisher or from Amazon.com.
Interested in reading Ecumenism Means You, Too? Order the book directly from the publisher or from Amazon.com.
Monday, July 30, 2012
Baptists and Episcopalians together?
This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.
In my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity, I suggested this as something that “ordinary Christians” can do locally to further the visible unity of the church: “If your own denomination has been in…official dialogue with other churches, studying and discussing these reports would be an ideal way to learn about other denominations and their relationship to your own tradition” (pp. 63-64).
Two churches in Shelby, NC, tried that suggestion out together this summer. For the second year in a row, Ross Grove Baptist Church and the Episcopal Church of the Redeemer combined their resources to hold a joint Vacation Bible School, which this summer also featured an “adult track.” The world communions of the two churches, the Baptist World Alliance and the Anglican Communion, held a series of conversations 2000-2005 that produced a substantial study text. In connection with that document, I led a group of members from both congregations in a study of the theme “Baptists and Episcopalians, One in Christ.” Here are the topics we discussed:
In my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity, I suggested this as something that “ordinary Christians” can do locally to further the visible unity of the church: “If your own denomination has been in…official dialogue with other churches, studying and discussing these reports would be an ideal way to learn about other denominations and their relationship to your own tradition” (pp. 63-64).
Two churches in Shelby, NC, tried that suggestion out together this summer. For the second year in a row, Ross Grove Baptist Church and the Episcopal Church of the Redeemer combined their resources to hold a joint Vacation Bible School, which this summer also featured an “adult track.” The world communions of the two churches, the Baptist World Alliance and the Anglican Communion, held a series of conversations 2000-2005 that produced a substantial study text. In connection with that document, I led a group of members from both congregations in a study of the theme “Baptists and Episcopalians, One in Christ.” Here are the topics we discussed:
- “A Shared Story: From Separation and Persecution to Toleration to Ecumenical Engagement”
- “Common Prayer? Occasion for Division, Opportunityfor Convergence”
- “One Baptism? Comparable Journeys of Christian Initiation”
- “One Bread, One Body? Together at the Table”
- “So What? Living Into Our Unity”
This study was one of the most enjoyable local church Christian education events I’ve ever experienced. In many ways it was akin to one of the most enjoyable experiences in graduate-professional theological education I’ve had, an ecumenical theology course I taught at the Lutheran Theological Southern Seminary in Columbia, SC, that included 18Lutherans, three Baptists, two Episcopalians and two Methodists.
Participants in our adult VBS study were able to name and move beyond the stereotypical impressions they had of one another’s traditions. For Baptists and Episcopalians alike, it was also an opportunity to learn more about the rationales for the distinctive doctrines and worship practices of our own traditions, sometimes occasioning some intra-denominational questions that might not have occurred apart from this inter-denominational conversation. Some participants expressed the desire to visit worship services in one another’s churches sometime and gather for continued conversation afterwards.
Baptist participation in international ecumenical dialogue has yielded resources that could be used for similar studies with neighboring churches of other denominational traditions. Beginning in the 1970s, the BWA has engaged in bilateral dialogues with the World Alliance of Reformed Churches, the Roman Catholic Church, the Lutheran World Federation, the World Mennonite Conference, and the Anglican Communion. (The BWA has also held exploratory “pre-conversations” with the Eastern Orthodox Ecumenical Patriarchate and later this year will begin a series of conversations with the Pentecostal World Fellowship.) These dialogues have issued reports that can serve as study resources for the sort of grassroots dialogue we enjoyed in Shelby.
The Mennonites are Baptists’ closest denominational kissing cousins. If there is a Mennonite fellowship in your area, members of your Baptist congregation can get to know them by exploring together “Baptist-Mennonite Theological Conversations” (1989-92).
While Baptists represent a distinctively different stream of the Protestant tradition, its Reformation tributaries flow from the Lutheran beginnings of Protestantism. Join Lutheran neighbors in digging down to common roots by reading “Baptists and Lutherans in Conversation: A Message to our Churches” (1990).
Not all Baptists are Reformed with a capital “R” (i.e., Calvinist), but since the 17th century significant segments of Baptist life have identified with that expression of the Reformation. Whether you claim the heritage of Particular (Calvinistic) or General (Arminian) Baptists, the “Report of Theological Conversations Sponsored by the World Alliance of Reformed Churches and the Baptist World Alliance, 1973-77” is an excellent entrée to stimulating theological conversation with local Presbyterians.
Dissent from the Church of England birthed the Baptists, but as we discovered in Shelby, contemporary Anglicans/Episcopalians and Baptists now have much more in common and many gifts to share with one another. Conversations Around the World 2000-2005: The Report of the International Conversations between the Anglican Communion and the Baptist World Alliance (2005), edited by renowned Baptist theologian Paul Fiddes, is a rich and engaging exercise in ecumenical theological reflection that will enlighten members of Baptist congregations and Episcopal/Anglican parishes as they read, mark, and inwardly digest it together.
It would be difficult to imagine a more polarized pair of ecumenical dialogue partners than Baptists and Roman Catholics. Yet the two communions have been able to issue “Summons to Witness to Christ in Today’s World: A Report on the Baptist-Roman Catholic International Conversations” (1984-88). Watch for a report from the 2006-2010 series of BWA-RCC conversations in 2013. Both documents will help Baptists and Roman Catholics learn to recognize one another, and learn from one another, as brothers and sisters in Christ.
At the grassroots, Christian laypersons of all denominations can be some of the most passionately ecumenical people one can meet, gladly embracing those whom they perceive to be following the same Lord. When they build on that instinct by reading and discussing these dialogue reports together, the dialogues will make their hope-for contribution to Christian unity.
[Note: The dialogue texts referenced in this post that are available online are hyperlinked. Most were also issued in pamphlet or booklet form, and all are included in the three-volume Growth in Agreement series published by the World Council of Churches: vol. 1, Growth in Agreement: Reports and Agreed Statements of Ecumenical Conversations on a World Level, ed. Harding Meyer and Lukas Vischer (New York: Paulist Press; Geneva: World Council of Churches, 1984); vol. 2, Growth in Agreement II: Reports and Agreed Statements of Ecumenical Conversations on a World Level, 1982-1998, ed. Jeffrey Gros, Harding Meyer, and William G. Rusch (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans; Geneva: WCC Publications, 2000); vol. 3, Growth in Agreement III: International Dialogue Texts and Agreed Statements, 1998-2005, ed. Jeffrey Gros, Thomas F. Best, and Lorelei F. Fuchs (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans; Geneva: WCC Publications, 2007). One of my current writing projects is the publication of a complete collection of texts from international, national, and regional ecumenical dialogues in which Baptists have participated. In the meantime, churches interested in taking up the practice of grassroots ecumenical dialogue I’ve commended in this post can find relevant resources in the places I’ve noted here.]
This post was originally published on the ABPnews Blog.
Thursday, July 26, 2012
Ecumenical dialogue at the grassroots
My post "Baptists and Episcopalians together?" appears today on the ABPnews Blog published by Associated Baptist Press. I'll post the full text here at Eccelsial Theology early next week. In the meantime, here's a snippet from the opening of the post:
In my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity, I suggested this as something that “ordinary Christians” can do locally to further the visible unity of the church: “If your own denomination has been in…official dialogue with other churches, studying and discussing these reports would be an ideal way to learn about other denominations and their relationship to your own tradition” (pp. 63-64).
Two churches in Shelby, NC, tried that suggestion out together this summer. For the second year in a row, Ross Grove Baptist Church and the Episcopal Church of the Redeemer combined their resources to hold a joint Vacation Bible School, which this summer also featured an “adult track.” The world communions of the two churches, the Baptist World Alliance and the Anglican Communion, held a series of conversations 2000-2005 that produced a substantial study text. In connection with that document, I led a group of members from both congregations in a study of the theme “Baptists and Episcopalians, One in Christ.” Here are the topics we discussed....
Read the full post at the ABPnews Blog.
In my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity, I suggested this as something that “ordinary Christians” can do locally to further the visible unity of the church: “If your own denomination has been in…official dialogue with other churches, studying and discussing these reports would be an ideal way to learn about other denominations and their relationship to your own tradition” (pp. 63-64).
Two churches in Shelby, NC, tried that suggestion out together this summer. For the second year in a row, Ross Grove Baptist Church and the Episcopal Church of the Redeemer combined their resources to hold a joint Vacation Bible School, which this summer also featured an “adult track.” The world communions of the two churches, the Baptist World Alliance and the Anglican Communion, held a series of conversations 2000-2005 that produced a substantial study text. In connection with that document, I led a group of members from both congregations in a study of the theme “Baptists and Episcopalians, One in Christ.” Here are the topics we discussed....
Read the full post at the ABPnews Blog.
Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Sarah Coakley on the theological implications of "evolutionary dynamics"
![]() |
| Prof. Rev. Dr. Sarah Coakley |
I've followed the work of Anglican theologian and priest Sarah Coakley since the 2003 publication of her book Re-Thinking Gregory of Nyssa in the midst of her tenure on the faculty of Harvard Divinity School. Now the Norris-Hulse Professor of Divinity and Deputy Chair of Arts and Humanities at the University of Cambridge, she is currently at work on an envisioned multi-volume systematic theology I've been eagerly anticipating for a few years. Its first volume, God, Sexuality and the Self: An Essay on the Trinity, is set for publication by Cambridge University Press in September 2013. In the meantime, I'll enjoy working through these Gifford Lectures along with readers of Ecclesial Theology.
Wednesday, July 18, 2012
Introducing "Running Heads"
Wipf and Stock Publishers, whose imprint Cascade Books published my book Ecumenism Means You, Too: Ordinary Christians and the Quest for Christian Unity, has launched Running Heads: A blog from the editors of Wipf and Stock Publishers.The blog will feature a weekly rotation of posts from editors Charlie Collier, Chris Spinks, K. C. Hanson, Robin Parry, and Rodney Clapp.
I'm impressed with the work this stellar group of editors is doing to advance the cause of academic religious publishing in the midst of the challenges faced by the publishing industry as a whole. They're also thoughtful and witty folks, and their blog posts will not be confined to editorial and publishing matters. Follow Running Heads here.
I'm impressed with the work this stellar group of editors is doing to advance the cause of academic religious publishing in the midst of the challenges faced by the publishing industry as a whole. They're also thoughtful and witty folks, and their blog posts will not be confined to editorial and publishing matters. Follow Running Heads here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






